Things were already going downhill at the house party, but after Chad, the star quarterback, starts flirtatiously dancing with your tomboy childhood sweetheart and new girlfriend Britt on the dance floor, you didn't think things could get any worse! But now he's invited her, and by extension, you, to the VIP area in the basement where he and 11 of his teammates are drinking and smoking. Just what does that egomaniac have planned to make your life miserable?!
I felt it only natural for the love interest to be your childhood sweetheart tomboy girlfriend who's made big strides on the girl's soccer team to become a plaything for burly jocks on the football team. It's football x football and you are caught in the middle. But feel free to remove the tomboy tone to it if that's not your thing, story should run well enough regardless.